Best and Worst Homeowners Insurance Companies in Florida (2025)
Homeownership in Florida comes with its own set of rewards—and risks. From stunning ocean views and tropical weather to the ever-looming threat of hurricanes, Florida homeowners know how critical it is to have reliable and comprehensive homeowners insurance.
In 2025, the Florida insurance market remains one of the most volatile in the United States, with several companies exiting the market, increasing rates, or failing altogether. If you're looking for the best homeowners insurance companies in Florida and the ones to avoid this guide will give you a clear, up-to-date breakdown.
🏆 Best Homeowners Insurance Companies in Florida (2025)
#1. State Farm
Why it’s one of the best:
State Farm is one of the few national carriers still writing policies in Florida. Known for financial stability, responsive customer service, and competitive discounts, it’s a top choice for many Florida homeowners.
- Financial strength: A++
- Customer satisfaction: High
- Unique perk: Bundling with auto or life policies saves up to 17%
Pros:
- Strong hurricane coverage options
- Local agents across Florida
- Fast claim processing
Cons:
- May deny coverage in high-risk coastal zones
#2. Citizens Property Insurance Corporation
Why it’s one of the best (and most necessary):
As the state-backed insurer of last resort, Citizens has become the go-to option for homeowners who can't find coverage elsewhere. It's grown rapidly in recent years as private companies have left the market.
- Financial strength: Backed by state
- Customer satisfaction: Moderate
- Unique perk: Often the only available option in high-risk areas
Pros:
- Provides access to coverage when others deny
- Improved online tools and customer service
Cons:
- Higher rates than private competitors
- May require flood insurance even in non-flood zones
#3. Tower Hill Insurance
Why it’s one of the best:
A regional favorite, Tower Hill offers competitive prices, fast claims, and several policy customization options that cater specifically to Florida’s climate risks.
- Financial strength: A- (Demotech)
- Customer satisfaction: Moderate to high
- Unique perk: Offers flexible hurricane deductibles
Pros:
- Florida-focused coverage
- Responsive claims support
Cons:
- Mixed reviews on customer service
- Rates vary greatly by region
⚠️ Worst Homeowners Insurance Companies in Florida (2025)
#1. Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Company (UPCIC)
Why it’s among the worst:
Universal has faced multiple complaints and lawsuits for claims handling delays and denials. Many customers report frustration after hurricanes or severe weather events.
- Financial strength: Unstable in recent years
- Customer satisfaction: Low
- Concerns: Regulatory actions and poor claim resolution
Cons:
- High rate of denied claims
- Difficult claims process
- Increasing policy cancellations in high-risk zones
#2. American Integrity Insurance
Why it’s under scrutiny:
Though once a growing player in Florida, American Integrity has seen rising negative reviews regarding customer service, surprise premium increases, and poor handling of hurricane damage claims.
- Financial strength: B++ (AM Best)
- Customer satisfaction: Below average
Cons:
- Frequent premium hikes
- Challenging claims resolution
- Limited coverage options in flood zones
#3. FedNat Insurance Company(Now defunct or insolvent in many areas)
Why it made the list:
Once a major provider in Florida, FedNat faced insolvency issues due to storm losses and poor financial management. Many policyholders were abruptly dropped.
- Financial strength: D (Demotech - before loss of accreditation)
- Customer satisfaction: Very low
Cons:
- Company collapse left thousands scrambling
- Claims unpaid or delayed for months
🧐 Tips for Choosing the Right Homeowners Insurance in Florida
- Prioritize financial strength. Always check ratings from A.M. Best or Demotech to ensure your insurer can actually pay claims.
- Read reviews. Customer feedback on claims processing can tell you more than a company’s marketing.
- Understand hurricane deductibles. Many Florida insurers have a separate (and higher) deductible for named storms.
- Ask about bundling. Pairing home and auto policies can save up to 25% in some cases.
- Shop early. The closer you are to hurricane season, the harder it becomes to find affordable coverage.
📌 Final Thoughts
The Florida homeowners insurance market in 2025 remains challenging, but by focusing on financially stable companies with strong customer service reputations, you can find a policy that protects your home and your peace of mind. Stick with trusted providers like State Farm, Citizens, or Tower Hill, and be cautious with insurers that have a history of poor claims handling or unstable finances.
Remember, the best homeowners insurance in Florida is the one that covers your needs at a fair price—and actually pays when you need it.
Post a Comment